The Takeout Names Most Overhyped Restaurant
A report names one overhyped restaurant in each U.S. State, citing declining food quality, poor service, or excessive focus on tourists.
The Takeout has published a list of the most overhyped restaurant in every U.S. State. The report, based on eatery history, media mentions, and critic and customer reviews, aims to warn discerning diners about potential shortcomings before they spend time and money.
According to the source, the list includes both bucket-list splurges and humble grills. All have been overhyped by local or national attention or throngs of tourists, The Takeout argues. The publication states it looked at ambience, service, value, and food quality.
Selected Criticisms Across States
The report provides specific critiques for numerous establishments. It attributes all claims to reviewers, critics, or the publication's own analysis.
In Alabama, The Takeout highlights Hot & Hot Fish Club in Birmingham. Although chef Chris Hastings won a James Beard Award in 2012 and the restaurant is Michelin-recommended, diners say it has gone downhill since a 2020 move. Customers reportedly say the food remains excellent but service is subpar.
For Alaska, Moose's Tooth Pub & Pizzeria in Anchorage is named. Despite a 2020 Tripadvisor ranking as America's No. 5 pizza spot, reviewers complain of long waits. A local Redditor reportedly feels it became a victim of too much success after a 2018 expansion.
In Arizona, the focus is Toca Madera in Scottsdale. The Mexican eatery features fire shows and live music. Reviewers, however, say it is loud and the food is mid for the price. One Yelp diner said you are paying for the ambiance, The Takeout reports.
High-Profile Establishments Under Scrutiny
Several iconic restaurants are included in the list. Their legendary status, the report suggests, does not shield them from criticism.
California's entry is The French Laundry in Yountville. It has held three Michelin stars since 2007. Some notable critics, however, feel it has grown tired. One Google diner who spent over $1,200 for two wrote you can easily get better tasting dishes elsewhere, the source states.
In Illinois, The Takeout names Alinea in Chicago. Michelin downgraded it from three to two stars in 2025. The New York Times critic reportedly wrote they expect more at this price point. One diner compared the overall experience to Disneyland.
Florida's selection is Sexy Fish in Miami. The underwater-themed Asian restaurant boasts $20 million in artwork. Diners say the food is mediocre or worse and it's too expensive. A Reddit commenter put it: "For the social media pics yeah, for the food nah."
Common Themes of Decline and Expansion
A recurring theme in the report is perceived decline following ownership changes or rapid growth.
In Arkansas, McClard's Bar-B-Q in Hot Springs was loved by President Bill Clinton. The McClard's sold their stake in 2020. One former Yelp fan said the new owners use cheaper ingredients, The Takeout reports.
For Iowa, Big Grove Brewpub & Breweries is cited. A local on Reddit reportedly said, "Unfortunately there's more money in expanding than excelling." Others agree the food has suffered recently.
The Varsity in Atlanta, Georgia, has hosted multiple U.S. Presidents. Some locals feel strong nostalgia. Others feel its best days may be over. The brand has opened four new locations since 2023; perhaps too much too fast, the publication suggests.
In Indiana, St. Elmo Steak House in Indianapolis is an institution where pro football deals are made. Locals agree you should go to say you've been and order the famous shrimp cocktail. Get a steak somewhere else, however. One Yelp diner said her husband makes a better fillet on their grill.
The report finishes with Kansas, discussing Joe's Kansas City Bar-B-Que. Anthony Bourdain put it on a list of "13 Places to Eat Before You Die" in 2011.
